April 06, 2005,
Yes, Virginia, there is a Social Security Trust Fund. Actually, Virginia, it's in West Virginia Parkersburg, to be precise.
President Bush traveled there Tuesday to visit the trust fund. Americans could be forgiven for thinking that he toured giant vaults brimming with gold bars, diamonds, real-estate deeds, precious antiques, and paintings by Rembrandt and Frans Hals. No such luck.
"A lot of people in America think there's a trust," Bush said, "that we take your money through payroll taxes, and then we hold it for you, and then when you retire, we give it back to you. But that's not the way it works...There is no 'trust fund,' just IOUs, that I saw firsthand."
What Bush found inside the H. J. Hintgen Building, not far from the Ohio River, was the trust fund's actual repository: The locked bottom drawer of a gray filing cabinet.
"Imagine the retirement security for future generations is sitting in a filing cabinet," Bush said in astonishment.
That drawer, inside an office of the U.S. Bureau of Public Debt, contains $1.76 trillion worth of special-issue U.S. Treasury bonds. Each of these, 225 pieces of paper in all, is contained in one of two white, loose-leaf notebooks that hold plastic page covers. Despite the protective plastic, these certificates have no more financial value than the ink with which they are printed.
"The paper is symbolic," Bureau of Public Debt spokesman Pete Hollenbach explained in a February 26 Associated Press dispatch. As a 2004 Congressional Budget Office report observed, the trust fund is an "accounting mechanism" with "no economic resources."
The key reason these notes have no value is that the money that should be behind them the excess payroll taxes not devoted to today's retirees instead gets spent by Congress on everything from farm subsidies to national parks to armored Humvees.
In fiscal year 2004, Cato Institute scholar Michael Tanner reports, the Treasury collected $570.7 billion in payroll taxes and credited Social Security with $89 billion in interest. Social Security recipients received $501.6 billion in benefits. This $158.1 billion balance which could have funded personal-retirement accounts instead flowed into general revenues. Congress spent that amount no differently than income-tax proceeds. In corporate America, this misallocation of funds is punishable by law. In Washington, it's the law.
Even worse, these special-issue bonds are not traded in the capital markets, where investors could infuse them with cash value. They are merely IOUs under which future Congresses will have to finance the Treasury's Social Security checks by raising taxes, authorizing increased federal borrowing, or cutting retirement benefits or other programs.
Beginning in 2041, Washington will have to bridge an anticipated 30-percent gap between what Uncle Sam will collect in payroll taxes and what retirees are being promised.
That task will be plenty difficult for the senators, congressmen, and presidents of tomorrow. And, as President Bush dramatized Tuesday, they will get precious little help from a drawer full of plastic-wrapped sheets of paper deep inside an Appalachian filing cabinet.
Deroy Murdock is a New York-based syndicated columnist with the Scripps Howard News Service and is on the advisory board of the Cato Institute's Project on Social Security Choice.